Review – Cliffhanger


The Cliffhanger: Gold Edition can be found on RPG Trader for $7.99. No affiliate link this time. Mostly because I haven’t looked into whether RPG Trader does it or not. I’ve been bad about my personal setup & usage of it.
44 pages (A5). Levels 3-4.
~ 3000 words. ~15 minutes to read.

I’ve watched Lucas working on this adventure in a game jam discord server for a bit now. Admittedly, I’ve given some feedback sporadically but nothing major. And not all of it used. Which is how it should be. I also cross-promoted the Kickstarter while my own was running for the Kumonosu Omnibus of adventures.

Some my motivations aren’t amusement or self-deprecation. Some times they are just, “this is a good guy and I’ve enjoyed watching the process of this creation from a safe distance.”

What is it?

This is a Shadowdark adventure for four 3rd-4th level crawlers by Lucas Ciquier, with illustrations by Fred Bertrand-Hudon. The book pitches it as 6-12 hours, so call it 2-3 sessions. It’s three pieces stacked on top of each other: a 7-hex mini hexcrawl up Mount Hush, an optional 8-area yeti lair behind a frozen waterfall, and the main event, a 6-area shipwreck dangling off a cliff above a monastery.

There’s also a rival party, the Burnt Sons, with free pregen sheets if you’d rather just play them.

Unique Features?

A Jenga tower.

Okay, technically it’s a player-facing pool of d12s. Every time a PC enters a keyed area or “rocks the boat,” you add a d12 and roll the whole pool. Any 1 and the ship slides a step closer to the edge. Six steps and it falls. (Shouldn’t have had that extra meat burrito for lunch.) The book also says, “If possible, I highly recommend using a Jenga tower.” Pull a block instead of adding a die. If the tower falls, the ship falls.

It’s a tested tension timer you can see on the table. One some people will be familiar with from other games, such as Dread. What makes it clever here is the topple means a topple. It’s a visceral consequences.

There’s also a madness of greed mechanic. I’m torn on it, because I like it, but I also think it probably would be better served in an adventure where it’s not sharing a mechanic spotlight with a tension tower, because now you have two tension timers. I typically enjoy conceptual density, but this is more mechanical density. I definitely need to play it to see how it feels. I have concerns only having prepped it, so I’m not holding it against it. I do wish there was a tracker sheet to make it easier to run though.

What’s the story?

A century ago, a string of calamities called Istovir’s Wrath flattened forests and sent tidal waves inland. One ship got washed all the way up Mount Hush and now hangs off a cliff over Mjola Monastery. Aboard is the Relic of Greed, a skull-sized chunk of an ancient shapeshifter that shows you whatever you want most. The captain grabbed it first. Her crew had to kill her and nail her to her chair with a pair of daggers. Then Greed got them too.

The two monks below would very much like it not to fall on them.

So… Adventure?

Setup

We get 3 hooks on p. 5, and they pull in different directions. Free drinks for life (and +1 to Carousing) for surviving a cliffhanger, the monks’ tithes to stop the wreck crushing the monastery, or Ol’ “Head-Hole” Jenkins, who’ll trade his sloop (400 gp) for the glass eye he lost up there a century ago. And the eye is actually up there, in the wyrmlings’ hoard in Area 4. A hook that pays off.

The monastery is your base. Two monks: Milkbrain, an ancient elf who believes she can speak reindeer (“and maybe she can”), and Sühne, a tattooed dwarven ex-fighter who feeds every visitor poutine. There’s a magic item called Blessed Poutine. It gives you a Luck token. Its curse is that it keeps taking up a gear slot for 24 hours after you eat it.

Milkbrain’s d6 rumors are short and actionable: the dragon, the Sky Needle, the cave behind the falls, the wreck glinting gold when the snow melts. They aren’t marked true or false, but as far as I can tell they’re all true.

The hexcrawl rules fit on one page (p. 12). Two hexes a day because everything is difficult terrain, a d6 weather roll, encounter checks twice a day and twice a night, rations, pushing, and a Light and Torches section. Consider it Shadowdark+. The torch matters here, and on a mountain that’s exactly what it should do.

The d10 Mount Hush encounters are active. A frost dragon wyrmling is losing a fight with an owlbear (or a unicorn, or wolves). The yeti is eating a dragon egg. 2d8 kobolds are prying spinels out of a rock face as “worthy tribute for the wyrmlings.” (Why did it have to be kobolds?)

The Wreck gets its own d10 table (p. 24), and five of the ten results add a d12 to the pool. So the mountain and its residents keep pushing the ship toward the edge whether the players do anything or not. (Just be aware that the Jenga tower and the dice do not align statistically. If you use dice, it’ll fall much more quickly.)

Hex Keys

Seven hexes, and almost all of them have an interaction button. You can climb a tree for the full map (Hex 1), hop ice floes across the river (2), climb the frozen falls at DC 18 (4), rest under the Sky Needle for a celestial boon (5), or dig for dragon eggs in a crater full of clutch bugs that look exactly like dragon eggs (7). The eggs are worth 300 gp each, and their mother has a 1:20 chance per day of finding out you took them. Or, in the book’s words: “Congratulations! You now have an excuse for a venerable frost dragon to hunt down your crawlers.”

Speaking of which, the frost dragon Syssyrax is result 1 on the mountain encounter table, and she has no stat block or page reference anywhere. So I guess… make it up? Or use the core book frost dragon block. Although, I think she should have a custom block if she’s a named figure. If she’s going to show up on a 1 in 10, I need to know what she does when she gets there. Especially since this is written for characters level 3-4 and a frost dragon is level 14. That’s in tolerance levels for a party to slay. (Which is an entirely different matter because it seems like that defeats the notion that dragons are meant to be forces of nature and here they are with stat blocks that mean you can ride a tornado. But I digress.)

The half-buried tent in Hex 3 comes with a crumpled note in a sidebar, written by a dead crewman: “All I saw was a couple dozen fools. Turns out I was right.” That’s foreshadowing as a handout. Print it. There are two blank pages at the back… make a hand out and put it there.

Behind the Falls

An optional mini-delve with its own Danger, Light, Secret Passages, & Water lines up top. The lone yeti, Kuaglh, is the last of his tribe and has “dedicated the winter of his life to one thing: killing dragons.” His encounter table is his schedule: he picks up your scent, gets hungry, or heads to the bathing pools for his beauty sleep. That’s a monster with a routine, not a monster waiting on a quest marker. He’s also on the wreck’s encounter table, hunting the wyrmlings, and he’ll add a d12 when he gets there. Everything on this mountain is connected.

The rooms are short, and a couple are just one line (the Thin Ice Wall, the Bathing Pools). But the Larder has a kobold hanging from the ceiling playing dead. So close, the the only good kobold is a dead one and we were right there.

The Cliffhanger

Six areas. Deadly: a 1:6 random encounter check every round. Midas mold turns anything non-magical into brittle fool’s gold, and anyone who drops to 0 HP from the insatiable dead has to make a DC 9 CON check or turn to gold and get back up on Greed’s side.

The levers here are good:

  • The Rowing Deck (Area 2). Searching the hold uses the treasure table, and every round you spend looting adds a cumulative 1:6 chance the ship moves. Greed is literally what drops the ship. That’s the theme as a mechanic.
  • The Gap (Area 3). An icy plank across a near-sized gap. Slide step 2 snaps it, making the gap double near and the DC 12.
  • The crow’s nest (Area 4). Wyrmlings, a hoard, Jenkins’s glass eye, and a DC 18 climb that adds a d12 if you fall.
  • The Captain’s Cabin (Area 6). She needs 2 rounds to pull herself off the daggers. The Relic is in the dead crewmen’s hands, and prying it loose wakes every insatiable aboard.

Moldy loot. Everything non-magical aboard is fool’s gold until the Relic is destroyed. I love this, but it raises a question the book doesn’t answer. Is fool’s gold worth XP? If not, the party has to deal with the Relic to get paid. That’s brilliant. If yes, it’s just flavor. Either way, I want a sentence telling me which way the creator thinks it should be run.

Let’s talk about how often that ship actually falls. The pool resets after every slide, so a slide takes about 4 triggers on average (mathematically speaking), and the full fall takes roughly 25 (anywhere from about 19 to 33). Six areas means six entries, plus encounters and whatever “rocks the boat.” So a careful party probably won’t drop the ship. A greedy party looting the hold may (still low odds). The book says the climax “varies from table to table” and might be the fall, the Relic, or both, and the math backs that up. It also sort of makes the Jenga tower predictable if you play with people who aren’t drunk. “Oh, it’s starting to get wobbly, we need to move now.” That kind of defeats the purpose of a tension timer in some respects. (Also good players can make it last significantly longer than the dice will allow.)

But if you want the fall to be the likely ending, start the pool with a couple of dice already in it.

If the ship does go, Cliffsurfer is a skill challenge: 8 successes before 3 failures, or everyone aboard (and in the monastery) is buried under 3d6 damage. Skill challenges aren’t a Shadowdark thing, but the sidebar on p. 7 explains them in a paragraph. It’s a good touch to explain a simple thing that isn’t overly familiar.

The ending gives you bonus XP for destroying or safeguarding the Relic (+3), saving the monastery (+2), and surviving the surf (+1). And it lets a character take Greed as a warlock patron. Of course it does.

Does it hang together?

Yes, and that’s the strongest thing about it. It’s based more on natural consequences (to the more cynical among us, it may seem a little contrived) than the greed draw. It drew the dragon to the mountain. The dragon wiped out the yetis, so the last yeti hunts dragons. The kobolds hunt the wyrmlings, and the wyrmlings nest in the wreck. Every faction on Mount Hush ends up at the Relic, and the timer punishes the players for wanting the same thing. Compare that to a sandbox where the hexes only share a theme. Here, the hexcrawl is the approach to one question: what do you do with the thing everyone wants?

So who is this for?

This is for GMs with a level 3-4 party who want a two or three session trip that goes overland, then a mini-delve, then a set piece, and who like a timer the players can see and feel. It suits greedy players best, because the adventure is built to punish exactly them. If your group loots everything that isn’t nailed down (and some things that are), this will be a night they talk about.

It’s solid. It’s interesting. Some missteps, but there is a lot of slop that charges more and it’d be a shame if this didn’t get a look from you at a minimum.

I think I’ve been pretty clear about my distaste for kobolds as dragon simps so I’d probably change that. I’m also changing some of the goofiness to fit my more grim/horror tone, but there’s enough meat here for me to really mold this into a nightmare that suits my table. I think it’ll suit a lot of other tables, you just may need to massage the edges.

You’ll want to sort out Syssyrax, the XP question, and the Behind the Falls map before you run it. That’s about it.

If you made it this far, thank you. Now, I’m going to nitpick & nerd out on design. You have been warned.

Design Nitpicks

It wears something close to the Shadowdark look: black banner headers, blackletter display type, and black & white ink. But it does enough of its own thing that it doesn’t read as a template. Monster stat blocks sit in a side column right next to the room where they appear (and again in the back). Magic items sit in the margin next to where you find them, the crumpled note is a sidebar handout, and there’s a separate Crawler’s Map you can hand to the players.

So it reads like its own thing, but it still hews too close to the Shadowdark trade dress for my liking. I genuinely want people to push the boundaries and do their own thing more. We don’t need to hit Mork Borg‘s punk art levels, but I think there is adequate room for more self-expression through the design and layout. This is getting there. I enjoy it so I want to push it more. That said, it also makes it hard to critique the aesthetic design without repeating myself over and over again, so we’ll nitpick the niggles.

Map placement. Mount Hush (p. 14) comes before the hex keys, and the GM and Crawler’s maps (pp. 26-27) come before the wreck. Behind the Falls breaks the pattern, though: the keys are on pp. 18-19 and the map is on pp. 20-21, after them. These should be flipped.

DCs. Almost all standard: 9, 12, 15, 18. The one exception is the frozen hatch in Area 4, “DC 17 STR,” which also appears on the GM map as “Jammed: DC 17.” Why aren’t they 18? Make it 18. A lot of checks also don’t name a stat (“Climb (DC 12)”, “DC 12 or fall in”, “Locked… DC 9 to open”). You can make the call at the table, but it’s an extra decision every time.

Also, on the lock, I think it should be clear if the Thief can do it without time pressure without a check. Also, what’s the check to break it down as a Fighter if there is no Thief. This is one of those weird aspects of the game where guidance is disproportionately more valuable, because there is such a division of opinions on it.

Checks with costs. Strong. Nearly every check falls, drowns, ruins torches, or adds a d12. The weak one is climbing a tree in Hex 1 for the full map, which has no cost for failure. Make a failure cost an hour, or you could bring back the moss. Injuries also are an option.

Treasure XP. Gold values are everywhere, including on the d100 treasure table. That’s great. But XP isn’t noted on any of it, and moldy loot makes that matter more than usual (see above). In fact, I would suggest it’s necessary because of the mold.

Monster math. A party of four 3rd-4th level crawlers is 12-16 levels by the 1:1 guidance. Area 2’s 2d4 insatiable dead (LV 3) average about 15 levels. Area 4 has 2d4+1 (about 18 levels) plus 1d4 wyrmlings, though the dead need 1d4 rounds to free themselves from the ice. That’s deadly, and on a Deadly wreck, that’s probably the point. But insatiable rats at LV 7, with a bite that does 1 damage, read high to me. The reason to point this out isn’t balance, but so you can see where there’s a threat of a TPK and how silly it is that our frost dragon is level 14 and without a stat block. Also, every stat block uses Ch for Charisma. Z. We’re all using Z. I swear it. I’ll get him on the next one.

Layout. Entries mostly stay put. Area 6 spills onto p. 31 (the chest), but that’s on the same spread, so it’s fine in a console view. Still a problem for PDF readers on tablets or phones. It’s been eye-opening watching GMs run their livestreams while reading both. You can’t do console mode that way. The stretch-goal thank-yous to backers sit in the middle of the content (p. 16, p. 40). They’re sweet, but they’re a crowdfunding fingerprint in a GM tool. I think this is better served residing with the credits or at the end in a dedicated space where people can see it.

Art & credits. Illustrations by Fred Bertrand-Hudon, credited up front. The full-page wreck on p. 22 and the opening fiction on p. 23 (“a dangling arm waves hello from the crow’s nest”) set the mood better than any read-aloud box.


Leave a Reply